Two Tax Areas Prone to Claims

1. Income tax issues can become technical to the point where most of the burden for decision-making falls on the CPA. There is often a limit to how much the CPA can ask the client to decide in technical tax issues. “It’s much like a patient seeing a doctor about a serious, complex medical condition,” said Ron Klein, JD, CFE, CAMICO risk management counsel. “The problem and treatment are so critical that the patient will ultimately go with the treatment the doctor recommends. The tax professional must be sure of his or her competency and ability to render the best advice possible for the client.”

Loss Prevention Tips: Careful screening of the firm’s clients and engagements will help avoid “engagement creep,” whereby the scope of an engagement may begin to extend beyond the CPA firm’s core competencies. All clients and engagements should be re-evaluated at least annually to confirm that the firm is: 1) capable of performing the services required by the engagement; and 2) is performing the services often enough to be proficient.

There are also high-risk clients and engagements. Both can be identified with careful client screening. Much of the information needed to screen a new client can be obtained by:

• running credit checks,
• examining previous financial statements,
• reading the prior CPA’s management letters, and
• interviewing the client, the client’s key personnel, banker, legal counsel, prior accountants and auditors

“The CPA’s job is to advise and warn the client about alternatives and their possible benefits and risks,” Klein said. “Once the choices are made, document the reasons and the client’s involvement. The CPA may also get a second opinion from another tax specialist, much like a doctor getting a second opinion from another specialist.”

2. Entity selection issues generally involve decisions about Sub-S or C Corporation selection or conversion. Clients make choices about S corporation elections because they believe the benefits of their choices outweigh the detriments. But sometimes events occurring after the choice make it less beneficial than originally planned, exposing the CPA to liability. Often CPA liability results from inadequate consultations with clients before these decisions are made. For example, a consultation should occur (which may not result in an S election) when a closely held C corporation holds substantially appreciated assets.

Loss Prevention Tips: Provide the client with a full consultation describing all negative and positive tax ramifications involved, and document the consultation in an “informed consent” letter, providing a brief summary of the issues discussed. Also, provide an area at the bottom of the letter which: 1) allows the client to indicate they have read and understand the summary letter; and 2) provides the client an opportunity to affirmatively indicate whether they want an S election. “Informed consent” is always important but more so in these situations because of the technical nature and the limited ability of the client to discern the pros and cons. Documentation will prevent the client from later asserting that your firm is responsible for unexpected events or less-than-optimal results.

Share this post

Leave a comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Latest Articles

  • 05 Feb

    Five reasons why CPAs believe they will never be sued

    CPAs generally take every precaution feasible to ensure error-free work, but that may not be enough to ensure a firm's security. In our litigious society, it's wise to be prepared for that unexpected bump in the road. To help put this in perspective, here are five common reasons why CPAs d... read more

  • 11 Jan

    January Tip - Documentation Tips for Tax Season

    Jurors (who are members of the public) generally consider CPAs to be experts in documentation, and falling short of that expectation when faced with a liability lawsuit may be viewed by the public as negligent and below the standard of care for the services rendered.

    The fol... read more

  • 17 Dec

    War Story 113

    #113: Difficult Client; Tax Planning and Return Preparation Services — A client with high turnover and disorganization in its accounting and financial staff is not only frustrating, but also a liability exposure if documentation is not thorough.

    read more

  • 17 Dec

    General Data Protection Regulation

    General Data Protection Regulation ("GDPR") is a European mandate that went into effect on May 25, 2018. The regulation is designed to establish uniform data privacy law across the European Union, and applies to any EU established business, including U.S. companies and firms with offices i... read more